How to Compare Contractor Bids
Three bids can look like three different projects. One is thousands lower, one has a start date next week and one is a single page with a single number. Comparing them fairly takes a method, and it starts before the bids come in.
- Licensed and insured
- Free for homeowners
- Only the pros you pick

Start with one written scope
Every bid should answer the same question. Write down the project in plain words: what is being replaced or built, the materials you want, any dates that matter and what you do not want touched. Give the same list to every pro. When the scope is the same, the differences between bids become meaningful.
Our project brief builder turns a few clicks into a written scope you can send to each pro.
Line the bids up side by side
Put the bids in a table with one column per pro. Rows should be the things that decide a project: total price, start date, how long the job takes, what materials and brands are named, who pulls the permit, cleanup and disposal, payment schedule and warranty. Blank cells tell you what to ask.
- Total price and what it covers
- Materials, brands and product lines named
- Permit, cleanup and haul-away
- Start date and how many days of work
- Deposit and payment schedule
- Warranty on materials and on labor
Look at what is missing, not just what is there
A low bid is not always a bargain. It may leave out decking repair, trim, permit fees, disposal or a cleanup. Ask each pro what happens if the crew finds a surprise, and whether it is priced per unit so you know the cost before work begins.
Check the person behind the number
Ask for the contractor's license number where one is required, proof of insurance and a few recent local references. Confirm the license with the state and call the insurance company to confirm the policy is active. A good pro expects this and sends it quickly.
Read the payment terms
A small deposit with payments tied to progress protects you. Be careful with large upfront payments or pressure to pay in cash. The final payment should come after a walk-through and a short punch list.
Decide, and tell the others
Choose the bid that fits your scope, schedule and comfort with the pro, not only the lowest number. Let the other pros know politely. They put time into their bids, and you may need one of them for the next project.
Related guides
Ready to get your bids? Raise your paddle.